We've all been there—falling into the trap of offering rewards as an easy way to get our kids to do things. After all, what harm could it do, right? Well, let's talk about the Overjustification Effect, a psychological concept that sheds light on why this might not be the best approach.
It's guaranteed we have fallen into this trap, whether we are aware of it or not. So what is it exactly?
It's what happens when you enjoy an activity simply because you enjoy it, but then you start getting something more, or rewarded for doing what you were already doing.
Your genuine interest in the activity takes a hit. The extra reward push the joy to the backseat and now the rewards need to continue coming to get that same feeling of joy.
And so what happens when the rewards stop? Well... there goes the joy in the activity altogether.
Kids and Grown-Ups Are in This Together: Overjustification Effect doesn't play favourites. It's there for both kids and grown-ups. Imagine your kid loves drawing, and you start giving them stickers every time they doodle. At first, it sounds harmless, right? But over time, the stickers become the focus, and the simple pleasure of drawing starts fading away. Just as much as giving them lots of praise, stopping for ice cream, or special treatment for doing well at something.
The TV-Chips Combo: A Classic Example Now, let's dive into a real-life example we've all experienced. Picture this: you adore kicking back and watching your favourite TV shows. It's your ultimate chill-out mode. One day, you snack on some mouthwatering chips while catching up on your series. It's a match made in heaven! But here's where the Overjustification Effect sneaks in. Over time, your brain links TV time with chip munching. Now, it's hard to watch without those chips, and it's equally tough to munch chips without a show on. They've become a duo you can't separate. It's something I have had to stop in many households with children. Parents confuse their child's boredom and stimulation with needing to eat while watching TV with them still being hungry. But once you separate the two, they don't want to watch the TV and they don't want to eat. Just like us sitting at the table scrolling Facebook or Youtube while having our breakfast in the morning. We can't simply, 'enjoy,' our meals anymore.
How It Affects Behaviour So, what's the big deal with rewards? Well, overloading an activity with rewards can mess with our natural love for it. Imagine kids getting treats for cleaning their rooms. Over time, the focus shifts from room cleaning being a responsible thing to do, to just getting those treats. And when the treats stop, guess what happens? The room-cleaning enthusiasm takes a nosedive. This is imperative to remember for adults and children that struggle with motivation deficits such as ADHD and other conditions that affect executive functions.
It should serve as a reminder that we need that balance. We need to be careful not to unknowingly dim the sparkle of things we love. The secret? Embrace the joy of doing things for the sheer pleasure they bring. Whether it's kids colouring, grown-ups working, or simply enjoying your favourite TV show, let's keep the natural excitement alive. So, go on—dive into those activities you adore, and let the pure fun flow!